The role that precedent plays in constitutional decision making is a perennially divisive subject among scholars of law and American politics. The debate rages over both empirical and normative aspects of the issue: To what extent are the Supreme Court, Congress, and the executive branch constrained by precedent? To what extent should they be? Taking up a topic long overdue for comprehensive treatment, Michael Gerhardt connects the vast social science data and legal
scholarship to provide the most wide-ranging assessment of precedent in several decades.
Updated to reflect recent legal cases, The Power of Precedent clearly outlines the major issues in the continuing debates on the significance of precedent and evenly considers all sides. For the Supreme Court, precedents take many forms, including not only the Court's past opinions, but also norms, historical practices, and traditions that the justices have deliberately chosen to follow. In these forms, precedent exerts more force than is commonly acknowledged. This force is
encapsulated in the implementation and recognition of what Gerhardt calls the "golden rule of precedent," a major dynamic in constitutional law. The rule calls upon justices and other public authorities to recognize that since they expect others to respect their own precedents, they must provide the same respect to
others' precedents. Gerhardt's extensive exploration of precedent leads him to formulate a more expansive definition of it, one that encompasses not only the prior constitutional decisions of courts but also the constitutional judgments of other public authorities. Gerhardt concludes his study by looking at what the future holds for the concept, as he examines the decisions and attitudes toward precedent exhibited by the shift from the Rehnquist to the Roberts Court.
Authoritative and incisive, Gerhardt presents an in-depth look at this central yet understudied phenomenon at the core of all constitutional conflicts and one of undeniable importance to American law and politics. Ultimately, The Power of Precedent vividly illustrates how constitutional law is made and evolves both in and outside of the courts.
Publisher: Oxford University Press Inc
Number of pages: 368
Weight: 522 g
Dimensions: 234 x 155 x 19 mm
"To seek a 'solution' to the problem of precedent is probably like trying to square a circle. Whether or not one agrees with Michael Gerhardt's particular solution, all readers will find themselves illuminated by Gerhardt's consistently interesting arguments (and the data on which they are built) and the insights they throw on the actual operation of the United States Supreme Court and its justices."--Sanford Levinson, Chair of Law and Professor of Government, University of Texas-Austin, and author of Our Undemocratic Constitution
"Michael Gerhardt's sophisticated and subtle book is the definitive treatment of how precedent really works in constitutional law. It should be the starting point for all future discussions of this important issue."--David A. Strauss, Professor of Law, University of Chicago Law School, and author of The Living Constitution
"When the subject is precedent, social scientists and legal academics often talk past each other. Gerhardt takes the time to listen. The result is a sophisticated yet sensible and accessible account of the role precedent plays in judicial decisions. But more than that, it is an account that no side in the debate can afford to ignore because Gerhardt ignores no side. At long last, let the conversation begin."--Lee Epstein, Professor, Northwestern University, and co-author of Advice and Consent