Naturalism in Question (Paperback)
  • Naturalism in Question (Paperback)
zoom

Naturalism in Question (Paperback)

(editor), (editor)
£30.95
Paperback 350 Pages
Published: 01/09/2008
Notify me when available

Stay one step ahead and let us notify you when this item is next available to order.

Today the majority of philosophers in the English-speaking world adhere to the "naturalist" credos that philosophy is continuous with science, and that the natural sciences provide a complete account of all that exists--whether human or nonhuman. The new faith says science, not man, is the measure of all things. However, there is a growing skepticism about the adequacy of this complacent orthodoxy. This volume presents a group of leading thinkers who criticize scientific naturalism not in the name of some form of supernaturalism, but in order to defend a more inclusive or liberal naturalism.

The many prominent Anglo-American philosophers appearing in this book--Akeel Bilgrami, Stanley Cavell, Donald Davidson, John Dupré, Jennifer Hornsby, Erin Kelly, John McDowell, Huw Price, Hilary Putnam, Carol Rovane, Barry Stroud, and Stephen White--do not march in lockstep, yet their contributions demonstrate mutual affinities and various unifying themes. Instead of attempting to force human nature into a restricted scientific image of the world, these papers represent an attempt to place human nature at the center of renewed--but still scientifically respectful--conceptions of philosophy and nature.

Publisher: Harvard University Press
ISBN: 9780674030411
Number of pages: 350
Dimensions: 235 x 156 mm


MEDIA REVIEWS

Naturalism in Question is undertaking an important task—to address the prevalence of scientific naturalism as the paradigm of serious philosophical work in contemporary Anglo-American philosophy. The fact that such eminent philosophers as Davidson, Cavell, McDowell, Stroud, and Putnam are brought together around a common issue is itself an attractive feature. It provides a certain landscape of contemporary American Philosophy that is most important to bring into view. It shows that despite all their obvious differences, such philosophers can be seen as sharing a similar concern to revive a form of philosophy that does not model its rigor on problematic pictures of scientific work. - Eli Friedlander, author of Signs of Sense: Reading Wittgenstein’s Tractatus

The book's concern with how to position philosophy with respect to science and nature is absolutely central to contemporary philosophical discussion. The contributors are distinguished and talented philosophers, and their articles in this volume will sustain and reinforce their reputation for philosophical clarity and insight. The more expansive naturalisms they advocate are important, constructive, and often provocative responses to a growing recognition of the inadequacies of naturalist orthodoxy. The book thereby promises to be at the center of a renewed discussion of naturalism, which will likely push the entire field in new directions. - Joseph Rouse, author of How Scientific Practices Matter: Reclaiming Philosophical Naturalism

De Caro and Macarthur's ambitious collection Naturalism in Question is a call to arms for opponents of the set of related doctrines that constitute scientific naturalism. It includes critiques of these doctrines from such luminaries as Barry Stoud, Hilary Putnam, John McDowell, Donald Davidson, Jennifer Hornsby, and Stanley Cavell, among others. Scientific naturalism is, in a nutshell, the view that the physical sciences should be given pride of place in our ontological, epistemological, and semantic endeavors. Operationally, this involves requiring that the concepts, posits, and methodologies of disciplines outside the physical sciences be shown to be suitably related to scientific concepts, posits, and methodologies, or be judged suspect. And suitable relatedness to the physical sciences is more often than not taken to require some form of reducibility...Naturalism in Question contains a number of gems. - Peter Alward, Philosophy in Review

It is a remarkably congenial collection of papers by a distinguished lineup of philosophers. There are two different types of argument to be found in these papers. The first shows how an uncritical adoption of this orthodox naturalist institution either misconstrues or underdetermines phenomena such as science itself, the mind, agency, ethics, and personal identity. On the second line, what is needed to avoid straying into the impasses of underdetermination (as the orthodox naturalist does) and dualism (as the normativist does) is a fresh and unbiased look at our conception of 'nature,' 'the natural,' 'naturalism,' and kindred concepts such as those of 'dispositions,' 'causation,' and 'science'...The result is a critical view of the explanans that is taken for granted by the orthodox naturalist, and used by the normativist as a foil for defining normative relations. Pursuing this line of argument is necessary if we want to avoid the shortcomings of both orthodox naturalist and normativist approaches to key phenomena in contemporary thinking. For anyone with such interests, and for anyone interested in the role of the concept of 'nature' and kindred concepts in their thinking, this collection will prove to be very instructive. - Jacob Lindgaard, Philosophical Books

De Caro and Macarthur's edited collection Naturalism in Question is a timely contribution which questions the nature and status of naturalism and hints at alternative conceptions to the influential widespread "scientific" form. - Tim Thornton, History and Philosophy of Life Sciences

You may also be interested in...

Determined
Added to basket
£12.99   £10.99
Paperback
Humanly Possible
Added to basket
£10.99   £9.49
Paperback
Meditations
Added to basket
£8.99
Paperback
Humankind
Added to basket
£9.99
Paperback
In Ascension
Added to basket
£9.99   £8.49
Paperback
Four Thousand Weeks
Added to basket
The War on the West
Added to basket
The Daily Laws
Added to basket
£10.99   £9.49
Paperback
Who's Afraid of Gender?
Added to basket
£25.00   £20.99
Hardback
The Myth of Sisyphus
Added to basket
The Cat Who Taught Zen
Added to basket
Ikigai
Added to basket
£14.99
Hardback
Why We Die
Added to basket
£25.00   £21.99
Hardback
The Creative Act
Added to basket
£27.00   £22.99
Hardback
Meditations
Added to basket
£12.99
Hardback

Please sign in to write a review

Your review has been submitted successfully.

env: aptum
branch: